Forum for Pigeon Fanciers
 
HomeHome  PortalPortal  CalendarCalendar  GalleryGallery  FAQFAQ  SearchSearch  UsergroupsUsergroups  RegisterRegister  Log in  Report a StrayReport a Stray  UK Pigeon SalesUK Pigeon Sales  Jack Barkel Website.Jack Barkel Website.  Friendslofts WebsiteFriendslofts Website  Velocity CalculatorVelocity Calculator  Portal 2Portal 2  ebayebay  
Latest topics
» This morning on loft.
by halcanada Today at 2:37 am

» Praise for a change. OFF TOPIC
by MISTY Yesterday at 11:54 pm

» Club meeting today
by MISTY Yesterday at 11:35 pm

» Another off topic...
by MISTY Yesterday at 11:25 pm

» Weather today
by Knackered Yesterday at 9:47 pm

» Different methods.
by Knackered Yesterday at 8:57 pm

» Mnfc olr 2018
by oldstrain Yesterday at 7:01 am

» Hen show coming?
by Boosey Sun Dec 09, 2018 9:47 am

» Write to the council
by Knackered Sat Dec 08, 2018 8:50 am

Forum Syndicate
Pigeon World Syndicate Bird takes 81st Place in the 2017 Final Race, The Bird is Dia Evans Bloodlines and was Bred and supplied by Tumley Lofts Stud.
R.P.R.A Certificate.
Pigeon World Forum Syndicate take 81st Place in the 2017 R.P.R.A. Final, with a Pigeon Bred and Supplied by Tumley Lofts Stud.
Who is online?
In total there are 22 users online :: 1 Registered, 0 Hidden and 21 Guests :: 2 Bots

Boosey

Most users ever online was 144 on Thu Apr 05, 2012 11:37 am
Bucktons 2017 Calendar
Pigeon World Forum, Fancier of the Year Trophy.
Top posting users this week
Knackered
 
MISTY
 
peel bros
 
halcanada
 
Daz
 
fieldwalker
 
oldstrain
 
Boosey
 
Similar topics
    Statistics
    We have 1155 registered users
    The newest registered user is whiteashbob

    Our users have posted a total of 172678 messages in 11377 subjects
    Log in
    Username:
    Password:
    Log in automatically: 
    :: I forgot my password
    Oldstrain/Darren`s Winner of winners. 2012.
    From Fed Topper to Master Chef
    The N.E.H.U race from Melton Mowbray 21/4/2012 was won by Peel bros of South Shields, they took 1st club 1st fed, also taking 2nd and 4th club and 15 of the 25 birds clocked in the club......well done Peel brothers.
    John Gibbs young pied/grizzle winner.
    Top posters
    David
     
    Don Webb
     
    oldstrain
     
    IANYOUNG
     
    peel bros
     
    Knackered
     
    Gaz b
     
    birdy2011
     
    Rene A
     
    halcanada
     

    Share | 
     

     Homing instincs

    Go down 
    AuthorMessage
    Daz
    Hatchling
    Hatchling


    Posts : 400
    Join date : 2018-07-15

    PostSubject: Homing instincs    Mon Nov 05, 2018 3:09 pm


    By Josh Fischman - The Chronicle

    The swallows will still come back to Capistrano, albatrosses will wing their way across vast oceans, and homing pigeons will still arrive at home. But scientists are no longer sure how they do it. If indeed they ever have been. Conjecture at most.

    Until last week, some thought they had a pretty good idea. Birds had both a magnetic compass and a map that they followed over impossibly long distances. But research published in the latest issue of Nature shows that map-sensing cells that were supposedly built into a bird's beak don't really exist. The cells that researchers thought were there are actually of a completely different kind.

    "They are immune cells called macrophages, and not neurons that communicate with the brain," says David Keays, a neuroscientist at the Institute of Molecular Pathology, in Vienna, and lead author of the new paper. "They can't detect magnetic fields."

    "I think this knocks the field back 10 to 15 years," says Henrik Mouritsen, a professor of biology at the University of Oldenburg, in Germany, who studies bird navigation. "That's a good thing. Usually negative results like this don't get published by prominent journals. But the original paper claiming these beak cells existed was cited at least 100 times, so this is a very important correction." Another critic has charged that a separate journal has been sitting on a different debunking paper for four years, neither accepting nor rejecting it, which he says caused many researchers to waste their time.

    One of the original beak-sensor researchers has launched a spirited attack on the new work-"The great amount of data conceal the bad quality of the contents," says Gerta Fleissner, a neurobiologist at the Goethe University of Frankfurt-but the critics appear to be carrying the day. "Birds have magnetic sensors, but these beak cells aren't part of the picture," says Joseph Kirschvink, a professor of geobiology at the California Institute of Technology.

    Two types of magnetic senses have been found in many animals, from bacteria to sea turtles. Essentially the creatures use a compass and a map to get around. The compass is formed within cells by tiny grains of a mineral called magnetite that reacts, like compass needles, to the north-south direction of earth's magnetic field. "In bacteria, they really are sensitive, like beautiful little needles," says Mr. Kirschvink, who helped discover them some 30 years ago. Behavioral experiments with turtles show they will turn to follow artificial magnetic fields, and turn again as those fields are reversed. Pigeons have shown similar behaviour.

    "It's not the compass that I'm calling into question. It's the map," says Mr. Keays. Biologists have assumed some map sense must exist, because a compass isn't good enough for finding your way. An animal travelling long distances also needs to know where it is. Magnetism can help here, too. For example, an iron-filled mountain would register as a landmark if a bird could detect magnetic intensity as well as direction.

    In two papers, one published in 2003 and another in 2007, Ms. Fleissner and several colleagues suggested they had identified the intensity detector. It was a series of neurons in six locations in a bird's upper beak, they said. The ends of these nerve cells contained particles of magnetite and maghemite, minerals that could react as a magnetic field got stronger or weaker, and transmit that information along nerve fibers to the brain.

    Mr. Keays says he was interested in these pathways, and wanted to quickly identify the six sensor locations so he and his team could move on to investigate how the information was interpreted by the brain. "I chose to work with pigeons because they have this incredible homing ability, and I honestly thought the work would go very quickly," he says. "But we couldn't find these six cell areas." Instead, in about 190 birds, they found a whole bunch of cells with various iron-related minerals in them. And that didn't make sense, he says, because the abundance would drown out any specific magnetic signal.

    "Then we got lucky," Mr. Keays says. "One of our pigeons had a beak infection. And looking around it we saw lots of little blue cells." He had used a blue stain, which binds to iron, to identify cells that contain the metal. "That made us wonder if all of these cells were actually immune-system cells."

    After slicing pigeon beaks into 250,000 very thin sections to examine them under a powerful transmission electron microscope, he decided they were immune cells called macrophages, which engulf invaders like bacteria. "We could actually see their little tentacles as they surrounded foreign bodies," he says. Macrophages often have iron in them because they recycle it from red blood cells.

    What they don't have, and what the researchers didn't see, was a nucleus. Neurons do. For Mr. Mouritsen, that was the smoking gun. "No nucleus means no neuron," he says. Even one of Ms. Fleissner's co-authors on her original paper is won over. "It is exquisitely and convincingly shown that the cells in question are nothing but macrophages," writes Michael Winklhofer, a biomagnetism expert in the University of Munich's department of earth and environmental sciences, in an e-mail. (He had previously expressed doubts that the minerals originally found were magnetically sensitive.)

    "Normally the best fanciers come to auctions and the best pigeons are on sale so I enjoy coming to them."

    Ms. Fleissner is not impressed. She responds that Mr. Keays's methods were poor, and he simply missed the cells that she saw. The sections he sliced were too big, she says, and could have missed the tiny neuron segments. And those areas should contain some neuron terminals, even if they don't contain magnetic sensing grains, but they don't show up in Mr. Keays's slides, leading her to question the quality of his cell preparation. "Not seen does not mean not existing!!" she writes in an e-mail.

    But Mr. Kirschvink has long had another objection to her work. Iron particles need to be highly ordered crystals to respond to earth's magnetic field, and Ms. Fleissner originally described crystals that were oddly shaped and amorphous. "That renders them useless as magnetic detectors," he says. Mr. Winklhofer agreed with him and in 2008, the two submitted a paper about this problem to the same journal that published Ms. Fleissner's 2007 work, Naturwissenschaften. And then: nothing.

    "We kept contacting them, asking them to accept it or reject it, but we could never get an answer over four years," Mr. Kirschvink says. "The last time we asked was two weeks ago. For a journal to hold onto a paper that long is really unethical." If the journal had published his paper, or let him submit it elsewhere by rejecting it, he thinks researchers like Mr. Keays could have saved themselves a lot of time. Other researchers have pointed to different cells, in fish, near their noses, that are stronger candidates for magnetic mappers-they have the right crystal structure-and he thinks Mr. Keays could have been hunting for those.

    The journal editor has a different view. Sven Thatje, a senior lecturer in marine evolutionary ecology at the University of Southampton, in England, wrote in an e-mail that he had not heard from Mr. Kirschvink or Mr. Winklhofer in three years, until they reached out to him a few weeks ago because they knew about Mr. Keays's upcoming Nature paper. "If there had been a matter of personal urgency, who would ever wait this long?" he wrote. "Pressuring an editor 2-3 weeks in advance of a competitive publication is odd and also a little academic." He also said that Mr. Kirschvink's paper fell into a gap as the journal switched editors, and that he had assumed the previous editor had dealt with it.

    The person whose time was supposedly wasted isn't complaining. "What I like about this paper is that it shows science is self-correcting," Mr. Keays says. "Someone, somewhere, will step up and set you right."

    Now, he says, "we are trying to find the real thing, the real magnetic sense organ. After all, birds must do this somehow."

    Back to top Go down
    View user profile
    MISTY
    Hatchling
    Hatchling


    Posts : 961
    Join date : 2018-01-28
    Age : 83
    Location : SCARBOROUGH

    PostSubject: Re: Homing instincs    Mon Nov 05, 2018 5:29 pm

    There are numerous theories regarding the homing instinct in birds and other animals.

    None have been proven one way or another.

    Numerous tests and theories have been entered into with absolutely no reasonable answers found.

    So many different kinds of animals depend on a kind of homing instinct that it is unrealistic to think that they all use the same means.


    I have known a dog travel many miles back home from an area never visited previously etc;


    Cannot understand why one should be worried about how, much better to make sure you give your pigeons the best chance to use it, choose what it is.

    Regards..




    Back to top Go down
    View user profile http://albertrosbottom35@outlook.com
    halcanada
    Youngbird
    Youngbird
    avatar

    Posts : 3437
    Join date : 2014-03-11
    Age : 78
    Location : Southern Ontario. Canada.

    PostSubject: Re: Homing instincs    Mon Nov 05, 2018 7:26 pm

    Why would any person want to identify the homing instinct? To enhance it? The homing instinct exsists to a greater or lesser extent in all pigeons. The way to find the birds with the best instinct is to fly them. All else being equal, I beleive the bird with the superior instinct will be first back. Simplistic? Perhaps. I have some cocks and hens in the stock loft that have previously raced and out performed the others.
    All distances/weather. Two red cocks in particular. This year only flew 2 young bird races. 1 st race my first bird was a white hen. Bred from a red cock x white American stray that came here covered in oil. No big money birds. 2nd was a red cock, close behind. He was from the other red cock.
    2nd race, light check hen was first followed closely by its nest mate, who was second previous week. Reds are old Jannsen strain originally.
    I have other young not flown yet. I would dispose of them but they will get a chance as yearlings. My intention was to cull heavy. Will do it racing them.
    Pic below of one pair.


    Back to top Go down
    View user profile
    MISTY
    Hatchling
    Hatchling


    Posts : 961
    Join date : 2018-01-28
    Age : 83
    Location : SCARBOROUGH

    PostSubject: Re: Homing instincs    Mon Nov 05, 2018 9:57 pm

    I would beg to differ regarding some pigeons having a better homing instinct than others.


    Yes there will be those unable to utilize it but all will have the same ability.


    Most normal humans (no detriment meant to anyone disabled) will all have two legs and the number of other such physical attributes but there are vast differences in how they can use them'


    A pigeons make up is decided at the stage of mating and nothing other than helping it to utilize to the full that which it was born with will make any difference.


    You cannot put anything in that it was not capable of at birth, it is finding out just what it is capable of and assisting it to reach it's full potential, that counts.

    Regards.


    Back to top Go down
    View user profile http://albertrosbottom35@outlook.com
    halcanada
    Youngbird
    Youngbird
    avatar

    Posts : 3437
    Join date : 2014-03-11
    Age : 78
    Location : Southern Ontario. Canada.

    PostSubject: Re: Homing instincs    Tue Nov 06, 2018 1:19 am

    I stand corrected.
    Back to top Go down
    View user profile
    Sponsored content




    PostSubject: Re: Homing instincs    

    Back to top Go down
     
    Homing instincs
    Back to top 
    Page 1 of 1
     Similar topics
    -
    » Cat Tracker Homing Device

    Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
    Racing Pigeons,Show & Fancy Pigeons :: General Pigeon News :: Weather-
    Jump to: